What We Actually Mean When We Call It Intuition

I recorded the conversation with Chuck Borden earlier that day. By the time I reached the airport, something he'd said was churning in my mind.

Chuck is a filmmaker. Forty years in the industry, ADHD. He talked about following his intuition when it came to decisions - the risks worth taking, the ones that weren't. He'd been doing this long enough that he just... knew.

I was watching a genuinely impressive storm outside the terminal when it landed: that's not intuition. That's forty years of data he didn't know he was collecting.

The thought has been sitting with me since - because it runs directly against something I've been hearing for years.

There's a claim that moves through neurodivergent circles with the confidence of established science: that people with ADHD, autism, dyslexia - wired-differently brains in general - have enhanced pattern recognition. That we see things others miss. That what looks like a hunch is actually the brain doing something sophisticated that it can't articulate.

I've said versions of this myself. It resonates. It feels true. And for a lot of people - people who've spent decades being told they're impulsive, irrational, going on gut feeling as if that's the opposite of rigorous thinking - it offers something valuable: a reframe that doesn't start from deficit.

So before I go any further, I want to be clear that I'm not here to dismantle something that has given people a more generous way of understanding themselves.

But I've been sitting with the research, and the honest picture is more complicated - and ultimately more interesting - than the popular version.

Here's what the evidence actually supports.

For autistic people, there is genuine, replicated research showing superior local processing - a facility for finding hidden detail within complex images, for attending to the specific rather than the whole. Laurent Mottron's work at the University of Montreal on enhanced perceptual processing is serious science. Something real is happening there.

For dyslexia, there's a narrower but real finding: a peripheral vision advantage that matters in specific professional contexts. A small study of astrophysicists found that those with dyslexia significantly outperformed non-dyslexic colleagues at detecting certain signatures in visual data - the kind of task where scanning the edges of your field of vision matters more than looking directly at something. Preliminary, small sample, but interesting.

For ADHD specifically - where the "pattern recognition" claim is most loudly made - the evidence is thin. The idea appears to trace back primarily to a 1993 book by a radio host proposing an evolutionary hunter-gatherer hypothesis. It was not a peer-reviewed paper. The creativity research that's sometimes cited (White and Shah, 2006 and later) found a real divergent thinking advantage - but at subclinical trait levels, not in clinically diagnosed individuals, and on specific tasks. The most thorough review of the literature concludes that the advantage, where it exists, may disappear at the level of full diagnosis.

What this means is that the bold claim - "ADHD brains are great pattern recognisers" - is largely extrapolation. Not fabrication. Extrapolation. There's a thread of something real in there, but it's been pulled much further than the evidence can support.

Which brings me back to Gary Klein - and to Chuck.

Klein spent decades studying how experts make decisions in high-stakes environments - fire commanders, military officers, intensive care nurses. What he found was that they weren't comparing options. They weren't running analysis. They were recognising situations. Matching what they were seeing to a vast, largely unconscious library of patterns built through thousands of hours of exposure. What we call intuition, in an expert, is really that library operating faster than language.

That's what Chuck has. Not a neurological trait. Forty years of film. Forty years of watching what worked, what collapsed, what risks were worth the exposure. His brain has been filing all of it - not consciously, not systematically, but filing it nonetheless. When he follows his instinct, he is following accumulated data. The fact that he has ADHD may be entirely incidental to that particular ability.

The reason this matters is not to diminish what Chuck is doing. It's the opposite. The recognition-primed decision making that Klein describes is a genuine cognitive achievement. It is mastery. Calling it "gut feeling" as if it's less rigorous than spreadsheet analysis is what's wrong, not the thing itself.

Here's where I want to stay honest with you - and where the picture gets more complex.

Many wired-differently people do develop a particular kind of environmental attentiveness. Not as a neurological gift, but through necessity. When the social rules feel unpredictable, you learn to read the room more carefully. When you've spent years decoding environments that weren't designed for how you think, you develop a sensitivity to what's underneath the surface - what's being performed versus what's actually true, where the tension is before anyone has opened their mouth.

This is real. And it produces something real.

But research on hypervigilance tells a sobering story alongside it - particularly in autistic populations, where studies find PTSD rates three to four times higher than the general population. Not primarily because of neurology, but because of disproportionately high exposure to bullying, social victimisation, and adverse life events. The research on ADHD points in similar directions: emotional dysregulation, a heightened sensitivity to rejection, a nervous system that struggles to stand down from threat states. Across conditions, the pattern is consistent. The constant scanning that many neurodivergent people describe is not a clean cognitive strength. It is, at least in part, an adaptation to environments that were frequently unsafe. It comes with a cost - anxiety, exhaustion, the particular kind of burnout that comes from never quite being able to switch the monitoring off.

Which means the attentiveness is real, and worth acknowledging. But locating it purely in neurology, as if it were a gift that came free of charge, misses where it actually came from - and what it cost to develop.

The survival hypothesis - that wired-differently people develop particular pattern sensitivity because they've had to - makes intuitive sense to me. It matches what I hear from clients. It matches my own experience. But there is currently no peer-reviewed research that directly tests it. It is a reasonable inference, not an established finding.

So where does that leave us?

Chuck's "intuition" is expertise - forty years of film, operating below the surface. The claim that ADHD brains have enhanced pattern recognition as a neurological trait is largely extrapolation from thin evidence. The attentiveness many of us have developed is real, but it emerged through necessity and it carries a cost.

None of that makes Chuck's knowing less remarkable. None of it means the sensitivity that wired-differently people carry isn't worth something.

It just means we might serve people better by being precise about what it actually is - rather than reaching for a superpower narrative that sounds good but doesn't quite hold up when you look at it carefully.

What stayed with me from that airport, watching the storm, wasn't the neuroscience. It was the image of Chuck - forty years in, knowing things he couldn't fully explain. And the question underneath it: how much of what we've been told is impulsive or irrational is actually something we've earned?

That seems worth thinking about.

If this landed somewhere useful, the coaching page is a good place to go next. Or if you'd rather just talk first, a Chemistry Call is 30 minutes - no pitch, no pressure.

→ Find out about 1:1 coaching

→ Book a Chemistry Call

Next
Next

Brilliant in the Dirt